How to Choose a Contractor: Questions to Ask Before You Hire
A lot of contractor problems start before the work does. Someone skips a step because the contractor seemed nice or the job seemed too small to bother.
I’ve hired trades for my own remodels and run my own projects as the owner-builder. When I want a second opinion, I ask two licensed contractors with more than 30 years each. This is the checklist I use. None of it is complicated, and most of it takes an afternoon.
If you’re in Idaho, there’s a section near the end on what Idaho law requires. Everywhere else, the rules vary by state, so check with your state’s licensing board or consumer protection office.
Start with a clear scope
Before you call anyone, write down what you want done. Rooms, materials, fixtures, what stays and what goes. It doesn’t need to be fancy. A page of notes and a few photos is enough.
This matters more than people think. If three contractors bid three different ideas of your job, you can’t compare the prices. A written scope also makes it obvious later what was in the deal and what wasn’t.
Know what kind of pro you need, too. A single repair might only need one trade, like a plumber or an electrician. A kitchen or an addition usually needs a general contractor who runs the subs, pulls the permits and keeps the schedule.
Where to find names
Good leads come from people who have actually had work done: friends, neighbors, a real estate agent who sees a lot of finished jobs, and other trades. A good electrician usually knows which framers and drywallers do clean work.
When the same name comes up more than once, put it on the list. Online reviews help, but read them for patterns, not stars. One angry review is noise. Five reviews that all say “never finished” are a pattern.
Check them out before they come over
Do this before you spend an evening walking someone through your house.
- License or registration. Look the contractor up on your state’s licensing site. Make sure the name and number match what’s on their truck, card or bid. Some states license general contractors and some only require registration. Trades like electrical and plumbing are often licensed separately.
- Insurance. Ask for proof of general liability insurance and, if they have employees, workers’ compensation. Ask for a certificate of insurance. Don’t just take their word for it.
- Complaints and court records. Search the business name with words like “complaint” or “lawsuit.” Check the Better Business Bureau and your county court records.
- A real address. A business with only a P.O. box and a cell number is harder to find when something goes wrong.
Questions to ask in the first meeting

- How many jobs like mine have you done in the last year or two?
- Who will actually be on site every day, you or a crew? Who do I call with a problem?
- Which parts will you sub out, and to whom?
- Will this need a permit, and who pulls it? (In my view it should be the contractor, with the permit in their name.)
- When could you start, and how long will it take?
- How do you handle changes once the job starts?
- What’s your warranty on labor, and who handles warranty on materials?
- Can I talk to two or three of your recent customers?
Pay attention to how they answer, not just what they say. A good contractor asks you questions back. They want to know what’s behind the wall before they promise a price.
Call the references
A lot of people skip this. Don’t. Ask whether the job finished on time and on budget, how changes were handled, whether the crew cleaned up, and whether they’d hire the same contractor again. If you can see a finished job in person, even better. Photos taken during the job tell you more than glossy finished shots.
Compare bids line by line
Get written bids from more than one contractor for the same scope. Then compare the lines, not just the bottom number.
Things to line up side by side:
- What’s included and what’s specifically excluded
- Materials, by brand or model where it matters, or the allowance for items you’ll pick later
- Permits and inspection fees
- Demolition, haul-off and cleanup
- Start date, finish date and how long the price is good for
- Payment schedule
- Warranty
The low bid is not automatically the best bid. When one price is far below the others, something is usually missing. Ask the contractor to walk you through it. Sometimes there’s a good reason. Often the missing piece shows up later as a change order.
Get it in writing
The contract should cover who, what, where, when and how much. At a minimum:
- The contractor’s full business name, address, phone and license or registration number
- The scope of work and materials, including anything they promised out loud
- The total price and a payment schedule
- Start and completion dates
- Who gets the permits
- How change orders work: in writing, with the price, signed before the work is done
- Warranty terms
Don’t sign anything with blank spaces. If a contractor sells you a job at your home, the federal Cooling-Off Rule usually gives you until midnight of the third business day to cancel. It covers household goods and services of $25 or more sold at your home ($130 or more if sold somewhere else away from the seller’s place of business), and the seller has to give you a written cancellation notice. There are exceptions. If you called them for a real emergency, you can waive the right, but only with a dated statement in your own handwriting. If you asked them out to repair something, the repair isn’t covered, though extra goods or services they sell you on that visit can be. If the contract is large or unusual, it’s worth paying an attorney to read it.
Pay as the work gets done
A deposit is normal, especially when materials have to be ordered. Paying most of the job up front is not.
Tie each payment to a stage of work you can see, like rough-in passed or cabinets installed. Pay by check or card so there’s a record. Hold the final payment until the work is done, the final inspection has passed, and you have the lien waivers your contract calls for from the contractor and the main subs and suppliers.
That last part catches people. In Idaho, people who do the work or supply the materials for a building have lien rights, and the contractor counts as the owner’s agent for lien purposes (Idaho Code 45-501). So an unpaid sub or supplier may be able to file a lien on your house even after you’ve paid your contractor, as long as they meet the law’s filing rules and deadlines. Other states have their own lien laws. Put lien waivers in your contract so you can collect them before you pay.
Red flags to walk away from
- Pressure to sign today to get a special price
- Cash only, or large payments up front
- No written contract or a vague one-page bid
- Asking you to pull the permit in your name, or saying the job doesn’t need one when it clearly does
- Won’t show proof of license, registration or insurance
- Leftover materials from a job down the street, offered at a discount
- Can’t give you recent references
Older homes and lead paint

If your house was built before 1978 and the job will disturb painted surfaces, federal rules require the firm doing the work to be EPA lead-safe certified. That covers remodeling, painting prep, window replacement, and electrical and plumbing work that cuts into painted walls. Ask for the certification.
If you’re hiring in Idaho
Idaho requires contractors to register with the Idaho Contractors Board. It’s a registration, not a license, and it’s required unless an exemption applies (Idaho Code 54-5204). One exemption covers a single casual or minor job that totals less than $2,000 for labor, materials and everything else. It doesn’t apply if the job is part of a bigger project, or if a bigger job gets split into small contracts to stay under the limit. There are other exemptions too, such as for employees and for owners working on their own property (Idaho Code 54-5205). Licensed trades like electricians, plumbers and HVAC contractors are covered by their own licenses instead (DOPL contractor FAQ). You can look up a contractor’s registration through the Idaho Division of Occupational and Professional Licenses (DOPL).
To register, a contractor has to show proof of general liability insurance, including products and completed operations, with a limit of at least $300,000. They also need workers’ comp or a statement explaining why they don’t need it (Idaho Code 54-5210). Registration doesn’t prove the work is good. It just tells you the basics are in place.
Idaho also has a disclosure rule for residential jobs (Idaho Code 45-525). Before signing a contract over $2,000 to build, alter or repair a home of one to four units, a general contractor has to give you a written disclosure statement and have you sign that you got it. It tells you that you have the right to:
- Require lien waivers from subcontractors (at your reasonable expense)
- See proof of general liability insurance, including completed operations, and workers’ comp for employees
- Buy an extended title insurance policy covering certain unrecorded liens
- Require a surety bond up to the value of the project (at your expense)
Before final payment, the contractor also has to give you a signed list of the subs, suppliers and equipment rental companies they hired directly for more than $500 of work or materials. Those companies are allowed to tell you what they’re still owed. Use that list before you write the last check.
If a contractor doesn’t hand you that first disclosure on a job over $2,000, take it as a warning sign. State law requires it. The exception is when you called them for a real emergency or for necessary repairs to your electrical, plumbing or water system.
The short version
Write down the job. Get names from people who’ve used them. Check registration or license and insurance yourself. Call the references. Compare written bids line by line. Sign a complete contract. Pay as the work gets done, and hold the final payment until you have the lien waivers.
More on building and remodeling: 2×4 vs 2×6 exterior walls, building your own home from blueprint to move-in, whether you really need new cabinets, and A/C maintenance for central air and mini-splits.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Laws change and vary by state. Check your state’s current rules or talk to an attorney about your contract.
Featured image: A house gutted for renovation in Mid-City New Orleans, April 2020. Photo: Bart Everson, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
